Thursday 3 May 2012

Final Cut




Audience Feedback


Amy Bowman- 17
Positives:

  • sound over logo grabbed attention
  • non diegetic sound
  • Introduction of main title
Negative:
  • Some titles were unreadable
  • At one point the camera was blurry

Alexander Cotton- 16
Positives:
  • Sound was good
  • Liked the shot of Harry sleeping when you could see the room
Negatives:
  • Did not like the use of titles
  • Could not read all of the titles
  • Monotonous

Sean Greenaway- 17
Positives:
  • Acting was good
  • Good use of music
  • Understood the plot

Negatives:
  • Some titles were distracting
  • Should have introduced Penny

Overall, this feedback shows that our consideration of sound was good and that it had a positive effect on the film. There was a general feel from verbal feed back that the viewers understood what was happening, but may not have fully. However, this is common for an opening as it is meant to encourage questions and encourage the viewer to continue watching.  However, it seems that the use of titles was not as well received as we would have hoped. In hinds sight, we could have made some of the clearer, for example the title shown on the bottle of pills could have been written and bigger. We could have also have shown them for longer. One comment showed that our opening was monotonous, which we hoped would have been resolved through the fast paced editing and turn of events seen. To overcome this, we could have shown Harry going about various aspects of his life or introduced other character, even briefly. 

Rough Cut Two




Charlotte Morrison-18
Positives
  • Good use of non diegetic sound
  • Good integrated titles
  • Good range of camera angles, tilts, pans and close ups
  • Obvious genre
Negatives
  • Could have varied camera angles
  • Shaky camera at some points
Mollie Rose Turkentine-17
Positives
  • Non diegetic music made story clear
  • good fast pace
  • Story line was clearer and easier to understand
  • Obvious genre
Negatives
  • Can tell actor is reading
  • Pill bottle out of focus
  • Days should have been made clearer
Caitlin Scott- 17
positives
  • Music matched and enhanced mood
  • Liked the integrated titles
  • Obvious genre
Negatives
  • Untidy handwriting
  • Sometimes it was unfocused (camera)
Steven Adcock- 16
Positives
  • Good use of lighting
  • Props were effective
  • Good music
negatives
  • Writing could have been neater
  • days should have been made clearer

Ellie Rose- 15
Positive
  • Understood the plot
  • Good use of music

Negatives
  • Only one character
  • Did not understand the time frame

Rough Cut One